The Miss America's Teens of New York
The Miss New York's Teen Legacy
Maria DeSantis
Miss New York's Teen 2006
Miss America's Teen 2007
Miss America's Teen 2007
2025 Nadia Anwar
2024 Erica Parks
2023 Sadie Perry
2022 Dajania James (4th Runner Up)
2021 Gianna Caetano
2019 Sarah Lawrence
2018 Cayla Kumar
2017 Asia Hickman
2016 Lauryn Whitfield
2015 Alisa Vasquez
2014 Cady Ruth Stoever
2013 Krysta Prehoda
2012 Shannon Ryan
2011 Lauren Molella
2010 Alison Stroming
2009 Kara Jae Kowalski
2008 Alexandra Mazzucchelli
2007 Alison Carlos
2006 Brittany Balandis*
2006 Maria DeSantis
2005 Amanda Lee Alicea
* Titleholder took over for Miss New York after they won Miss America or Resigned their title